← Research

Black holes · Higher-dimensional gravity

Doubly-spinning Black Saturns

A black hole within a black ring: two horizons, two rotation planes, and a new route to extremality.

Jay Armas · University of Amsterdam & Niels Bohr Institute

Explore the ancillary files ↓
A black hole surrounded by a black ringSchematic projection of two disconnected horizons: a central spherical black hole and a surrounding black ring. This is a conceptual diagram of a five-dimensional spacetime.TWO DISCONNECTED HORIZONSCentral black hole · S³Black ring · S¹ × S²Two rotation planes
Conceptual projection of a five-dimensional black Saturn. The ring is itself a black hole horizon, not a ring of matter. Shapes and arrows are schematic.
5 dimensionsAn asymptotically flat solution of vacuum Einstein gravity.
6 parametersA family describing a central black hole and a surrounding ring.
2 extremal horizonsBoth components can reach zero temperature with finite area.

The central idea

Two horizons. One exact spacetime.

Black holes in higher dimensions can have shapes and arrangements beyond those familiar in four-dimensional gravity. A black Saturn combines a spherical black hole with a surrounding black ring: two disconnected horizons held in a stationary, balanced configuration.

In this paper, I construct a six-parameter family of exact solutions with rotation in both independent planes. The second spin allows both components to become extremal, with zero Hawking temperature and finite horizon area. In the domains established in the paper, these configurations have a regular, causal exterior. To my knowledge, they provide the first regular, asymptotically flat vacuum Einstein solutions with two disconnected extremal horizons.

01 / EXTREMALITY

Zero temperature, without mutual equilibrium

Non-extremal black Saturns can share a temperature and both angular velocities. For the doubly extremal family constructed here, matching both angular velocities is incompatible with a regular axis between the horizons.

02 / INTERACTION

Rotation induced by a neighbouring horizon

The surrounding ring can make the central horizon rotate in the transverse plane even when that horizon has zero transverse angular momentum. Frame dragging separates a horizon’s rotation rate from its own angular momentum.

03 / NON-UNIQUENESS

The same charges, different geometries

Different black Saturn configurations can have the same total mass and two angular momenta. Redistributing these quantities between the horizons changes the geometry and total area.

From exact geometry to effective theory

Exploring the double-extremal family

The phase curves compare the exact black Saturn with extremal spherical black holes and black rings. A matched blackfold approximation captures the thin-ring regime, with agreement improving as the ring becomes thinner.

Four panels comparing double-extremal black Saturn area and spins with Myers-Perry and Pomeransky-Senkov solutions, and testing the thin-ring blackfold approximation.
Figure 3 from the paper. Purple: exact double-extremal Saturn; dashed orange: matched leading blackfold approximation; blue and green: extremal Myers–Perry black hole and Pomeransky–Sen’kov black ring. The final panel shows relative differences in the blackfold comparison. Both spins vary along the Saturn curve; the two horizons need not have equal angular velocities. Click to enlarge.

Research resources

Ancillary files

The accompanying material provides explicit metric expressions and computational resources for exploring the solutions and checking their properties.

The manuscript describes Mathematica expressions for the seven expanded scalar numerator polynomials and a metric evaluator, together with material supporting the thermodynamic, regularity and phase-diagram analysis.

Explore the solution

Get ancillary filesView and download the files on GitHub.

Connections

Known black holes as limiting cases

Removing the ring recovers the doubly spinning Myers–Perry black hole. Removing the central hole gives the Pomeransky–Sen’kov black ring. Turning off transverse rotation recovers the singly spinning black Saturn. The paper also constructs limits in which only one horizon is extremal.